2002 BMW Z3 Reviews and Ratings

Roadster 2D M

Consumer Reviews

Own this vehicle? How would you rate it?

My Rating

Fuel Economy
Interior Comfort
Ride Quality
Overall Rating

My Review

Type your review and click the Submit button
600 of 600 character remain

Customer Review

Be the first to review this 2002 BMW Z3.

Expert Reviews ( 1 )

2002 BMW Z3
Sam Moses

The 2002 BMW Z3 brings the rewards of six years of consistent and conscientious development and improvement. The exciting, odd-looking Z3 was BMW's contribution to the rebirth of the sports car that began with the Mazda Miata and has included the Mercedes-Benz SLK, Toyota MR-2 Spyder and other two seaters. However, the 1996 Z3 didn't reach the company's high standards of refinement, in particular with its suspension, but all of that began being corrected almost immediately.

And now we have the 2002 Z3. Its sawed-off looks haven't changed much (though now they're fully accepted). But the engine has jumped from the original 138-horsepower 1.9-liter four-cylinder to an available 225-horsepower 3.0-liter six-cylinder, reducing 0 to 60 mph acceleration performance from about 8 seconds to less than 6.

As the last model of its generation, the original Z3 won't get any better than this. Model Lineup
There are two Z3 Roadsters and one Coupe. Plus, there's an M Roadster and an M Coupe. The 2.5i Roadster is least expensive by a bunch, at $31,300. The 3.0i stickers at $37,900; and the distinctive Coupe goes for $37,700.

The three models use two engines, which were new in 2001. The Coupe and 3.0i Roadster use a 225-horsepower 3.0-liter double overhead-cam inline-6, while the 2.5i Roadster uses a 184-horsepower 2.5-liter version of that smooth mill with variable-valve timing. A five-speed gearbox is standard (beefier with the 3.0), while a five-speed Steptronic (manually operated automatic) is optional.

Significant standard features on all models are BMW's DSC (electronic stability program), vented front discs on four-wheel ABS, two-stage front airbags plus side airbags in the doors, a zero-maintenance battery, and Coded Driveaway Protection, an anti-theft system which prevents the car from being started without your key.

2.5i gets 16-inch wheels and leatherette upholstery (leather optional), with four-way power driver's seat and two-way passenger seat.

Coupe and 3.0i come standard with 17-inch wheels, leather, four-way seats, an in-dash CD player and Harman Kardon audio system (optional on the 2.5i).

Options include a power top or removable hardtop with heated rear window for the Roadsters; and, for all three models, heated seats and a six-disc player installed by BMW dealers. A Sport Package includes 17-inch cross spoke wheels and sport seats, plus brushed aluminum trim and a mesh front air intake.

In addition to the Z3s, BMW offers the M Coupe and M Roadster. Although these cars are in the M line with the five-seat M3 Coupe and Convertible, they're actually more like Z3s, using the same basic bodywork. If 225 horsepower isn't enough for you from the 3.0-liter Z3, the M is what you want, with a 3.2-liter engine producing a killer 315 horsepower. The Roadster sells for $45,990, including freight; the Coupe retails for $44,990. Walkaround
The Z3 Roadster is visually enigmatic. It looks funny, sporty, powerful, cute and homely, all at the same time. Which means people look at it for a long time, and it often makes them smile. You could say the same things about the Coupe, only much more so. People stop and stare at the odd-shaped Coupe, and often ask if it's fast. Anything that funny looking must be fast, they say.

The Z3 has a lot of curves and bulges, for such a short little body. It has a long low hood, yet looks truncated because it is, having a reasonable wheelbase but not much overhang, especially in the rear. The inline-6 engine takes up a lot of length forward of the windshield, so it's evidence of good engineering that the Roadster's weight distribution is a balanced 51-percent front, 49 rear. The hood also bulges in the center and has elevated edges that start at the width of the windshield and taper forward to surround the trademark twin-kidney grille.

There are still more dramatic shapes in the front end. Under the grille is a huge spoiler that would be at home on a racing car, including its gaping air intake between the foglights. The cool horizontal halogen headlights slide toward the grille, beginning just inside the bulbous fender flares, which are squeezed from behind by four louvers like shark gills, angled like a row of forward slashes: ////.

The back end is all bulges, with more fender flares. It's totally chopped off, almost no sheetmetal behind the tires. And this is the Roadster; the Coupe, with its boxy body, is flat-out radical looking. Interior
During the same week we tested the Z3 Roadster, we had a Honda S2000 in our driveway, so comparisons are inevitable. The Z3's standard leatherette seats are neither as smooth feeling nor firm gripping as the Honda's. There is decent lateral support in the standard Z3 seats, but they must be designed for smaller backs than ours; also, the pleats in the fairly hard seat cushion were more intrusive than the Honda's. In the S2000, we knocked off a 200-mile afternoon drive with nary a kink; the prospect of the same ride in the Z3 was inhibiting.

Later we got five days in a Z3 Coupe with the optional sport package that includes seats whose contour is both racier and more supportive, and this made all the difference in the world, changing the feel of the whole car. At $600, this package also includes great-looking cross-spoke composite wheels, making it a great bargain as well as a necessary option. In addition to their comfort, support and raciness, the seats in our Coupe were heated (another $500). The interior trim in our Coupe was brushed aluminum, which also added to great looks of the cockpit. The cargo area in the Coupe, separated from the seats by a short bulkhead you have to reach over, is quite tidy and convenient.

The leather-wrapped, three-spoke steering wheel has bumps inside the rim at 10 and 2 o'clock. BMW apparently believes in this traditional position for your hands, which allows your thumbs to use the bumps for better grip; but nowadays some instructors teach 3 and 9, which puts your hands below the bumps with your thumbs hooked over the big wide spokes.

There's a dead pedal for your left foot, but during hard cornering to the right, the edge of the otherwise convenient door pocket dug into the side of our left knee.

The instrument panel and gauges were redesigned in 2001. As one might expect from a performance-minded company like BMW, they're no-nonsense, intended to provide information to drivers. The switches were blessedly simple. Our test car was not equipped with the power top ($750), including wood interior trim. The power top would be a luxury indeed, as operation of the manual top is effortless. Driving Impressions
BMW's 3.0-liter engine is powerful, yet efficient. It gets good gas mileage and emits low emissions. It feels understated around town, unless you're engaging in continuous spirited squirts of the throttle, which is neither realistic nor particularly mature. Cruising on the highway, 60 mph comes at 2400 rpm in fifth gear, which is an enormously relaxed (other possible adjectives: under stressed, boring) pace for the engine.

This is a sports car that gobbles up the real estate and hungers for more. We didn't fully appreciate the Z3 until we drove it fast, and the faster we drove it the more we appreciated it. If you want to feel the fantastic smoothness of the BMW inline-six, try 6000 rpm in third gear, at which point you'll be pushing 90. That's a mere 500 rpm below beginning redline, but the engine likes it there, which may only prove how conservative that redline is. The rev limiter is smooth and sophisticated; at 6800 rpm the power goes radically away, as the engine simply and firmly lets you know there's nothing more for you. It's the best rev limiter in the business: no misfire, no snatch, no nosedive.

At low rpm, there's not much to write home about, but the torque is excellent so you don't have the work the gearbox a lot. The full 214 foot-pounds comes at 3500 rpm, and that's where you feel the engine begin to surge and the fun begin. The exhaust note also comes into its own, up there at higher rpm.

The throw of the gear lever seemed longer than it needed to be (especially compared to the S2000's racer-like six-speed), though shifting is smooth when you pay attention. When you don't, the upshift to second gear can be notchy. Our days in the Coupe confirmed this, as its second gear was notchier than the Roadster's.

Throttle response is excellent thanks to electronic control, and during downshift blips, it was downright wonderful. Especially for that common third-to-second shift, made even better by the pedal position that allowed smooth heel-and-toe movement during simultaneous braking and downshifting. Pulling away from a stop in first gear wasn't always effortless, however, as the ratio felt a bit tall.

The vented front discs on the 3.0 have been increased in diameter to a whopping 11.8 inches to accommodate the higher speeds delivered by the 225 horsepower. We have little doubt that the stopping power is all you'll ever need (with excellent ABS). We had one great run on a remote road with the Coupe through our favorite curves, and couldn't have asked for more from the brakes. Earlier in the summer we did that same run with an Acura TL Type S, whose brakes couldn't take it.

The Honda S2000 handles like a go-kart; not since the Subaru WRX have we felt anything that hugged the road so surely and turned in so quickly. The Z3 feels bigger (it's not, really), heavier (it is, by only 100 pounds) and slower to respond. But the Z3 turns-in very quickly. Almost too quickly, on sweeping curves that require more precision than aggression.

The Dynamic Stability Control (DSC) is magnificent. The Z3 might slide sooner than the S2000, but you'll hardly feel it before the correction occurs, triggered by sensors and computer chips. Unlike certain cars with more horsepower (the M3, for example), a loss of traction can be corrected without a radical reduction in throttle by the computer, so your driving is only enhanced, not interfered with. Drive the Z3 very aggressively over a bumpy, twisty road, and you'll see the DSC light on the instrument panel flickering like crazy, but you won't be aware of all the magic happening at your wheels-braking, reducing power-to keep the car true in its tracks.

On wet curves, you can deliberately drive beyond the point of adhesion, and DSC will act like a big invisible rubber bumper around the road. Of course DSC was never intended to be used like this, and in fact BMW specifically and reasonably warns against it. The point is, DSC works so well that it can be done. The problem is a philosophical issue: DSC is so good that it rewards bad driving, not good driving. But that's the future. And here's a question: On dry surfaces, does DSC mask handling imbalances in the car, or correct them? We could have attempted to answer that question by turning the DSC off (one switch on the dash does it) to see how badly the car understeered or oversteered as we drove like an animal, but à what would be the point? DSC is part of the car, period.

The grippy tires cause the car to wander over irregular freeway surfaces, but they were quite resistant to hydroplaning, given their width. As for the ride, the Z3 handles bumps as well as it does corners. It doesn't erase them, but certainly flattens the buggers. Drive a bit easier on that bumpy country road that puts the DSC to work, and you can relax and enjoy the ride. There's no harshness or jolting at all, which is impressive considering the suspension is still stiff enough to handle high-speed cornering on that road. But this is not unexpected, as it's one of the things BMW does best, a consistent quality in their cars. Summary
Engine, gearbox, brakes, handling, ride, electronics, safety, reliability, style, image à if you like the looks, the Z3 3.0i has it all. If the seat fits, wear it.

Model as tested
3.0i Roadster ($37,900)
Basic Warranty
4 years/50,000 miles
Assembled in
Spartanburg, S.C.
Destination charge
Gas guzzler tax
Base Price
Price as tested
Options as tested
heated front seats and mirrors and washer jets ($500)

Model Line Overview
Model lineup
2.5i Roadster ($31,300); 3.0i Roadster ($37,900); 3.0i Coupe ($37,700); M Coupe ($44,990); M Roadster ($45,990)
Safety equipment (standard)
antilock brakes, two-stage front airbags; side airbags; reinforced A pillar windshield frame and rollover protection hoops (Roadsters), dynamic stability control
Safety equipment (optional)
five-speed manual

Specifications as Tested
electronic stability control; 4-wheel ABS; leather interior; halogen headlights; power seats, Harman Kardon audio with CD player

Engine & Transmission
Drivetrain type
rear-wheel drive
Horsepower (hp @ rpm)
225 @ 5900
EPA fuel economy, city/hwy
Torque (lb.-ft. @ rpm)

Brakes, front/rear
11.3-in vented disc/10.7-in. disc, with ABS
Suspension, front
struts, control arms, coil springs, twin-tube shock absorbers, stabilizer bar
P225/45ZR17 front - P245/40ZR17 rear
Suspension, rear
semi-trailing arms, coil springs, twin-tube shock absorbers, stabilizer bar

Seating capacity
Head/hip/leg room, middle
Head/hip/leg room, front
Head/hip/leg room, rear

Fuel capacity
Trunk volume
Turning circle
Towing capacity
Track, front/rear
Ground clearance
Curb weight

J.D. Power Rating
Overall Quality Not Available
Overall Quality - Mechanical
Not Available
Powertrain Quality - Mechanical
Not Available
Body & Interior Quality - Mechanical
Not Available
Features & Accessories Quality - Mechanical
Not Available
Overall Quality - Design
Not Available
Powertrain Quality - Design
Not Available
Body & Interior Quality - Design
Not Available
Features & Accessories Quality - Design
Not Available

Overall Dependability Not Available
Powertrain Dependability
Not Available
Body & Interior Dependability
Not Available
Feature & Accessory Dependability
Not Available

J.D. Power Rating Legend
Among the Best
5 / 5
Better than Most
4 / 5
About Average
3 / 5
The Rest
2 / 5

* The J.D. Power Ratings are calculated based on the range between the car manufacturer or car model with the highest score and the car manufacturer or car model with the lowest score. J.D. Power generates a rating of a five, four, three, or two. If there is insufficient data to calculate a rating, a dash (—) is used in its place.

J.D. Power Ratings may not include all information used to determine J.D. Power awards, visit the Car Ratings page to learn more about awards and ratings.

Search car listings & find the right car for you
Click here for 2002 BMW Z3 Roadster 2D M local listings

Vehicle History Report

Get answers to buy with confidence
  • Check for accidents
  • Confirm the reported mileage
  • Purchase multiple reports and save

Car Buying and Selling Resources